How to defend a constructive dismissal case

Fsp Business, 16 Sep. 2013

Tags: constructive dismissal case, how to defend a constructive dismissal case, dismissals, labour law, labour law and constructive dismissal

Constructive dismissal cases are different to other claims of unfair dismissal where you must prove the dismissal was fair. When your employee claims constructive dismissal, he’s the one who must prove the constructive dismissal. So how do you defend this case as an employer? Read on to find out…

According to the Labour Law for Managers Loose Leaf Service, the definition of a constructive dismissal can be broken down into the following three elements:

Element#1: The employee must have resigned from employment.

Element#2: The employee’s resignation must have been solely as a result of your conduct.

Element#3: Your conduct towards your employee must have made the employee’s continued employment intolerable or unbearable. Your intolerable conduct must be the reason why the employee resigned.

This means, the Court will look at your conduct as a whole and determine whether your employee can be expected to put up with it or not.

It’s important that you have a good understanding of this as it’ll help you defend your constructive dismissal case.

Here’s a checklist for defending a constructive dismissal case

#1: Your employee must prove on a balance of probabilities that you constructively dismissed him.

To do this, your employee must prove he had no alternative but to resign because of your intolerable conduct.

#2: The court or arbitrator will look at your conduct as a whole to see if it something the employee can’t be expected to accept it.

#3: The court or arbitrator will judge your conduct objectively on what a reasonable employee in the circumstances would generally feel.

#4: Your employee must have exhausted all reasonable alternatives (such as the grievance procedure) before resorting to resignation and claiming constructive dismissal.

#5: If your employee proves he was constructively dismissed, you must prove that the dismissal was fair. In other words, you had a fair reason to dismiss and followed a fair procedure.

Remember, your other employees may also develop a feeling of insecurity and look for other jobs if they see you as a boss who victimises employees. You could lose good employees and may also find it difficult to attract good employees if your reputation is tarnished.

To avoid having to defend constructive dismissal cases in the first place, FSPBusiness stresses that you have a grievance procedure in place. Implement a non-harassment and bullying policy, where employees who feel that they’re being unfairly treated by, for example, a manager have a remedy available to them and a procedure they can follow.

But knowing what your employee must prove when he claims constructive dismissal will help you defend a constructive dismissal case.

Related articles:




RSS Facebook Share the experience
Labour and HR Club
  • CCMA
  • Discipline
  • Dismissals
  • Employment Equity
  • Employment terms and conditions
  • Foreigners
  • Laws / Acts / DoL
  • Leave
  • Performance management
  • Policies and procedures
  • Recruitment
  • Trade unions
Our experts
Ulrich Stander
Kirstin van Bever Donker Tracey Ndlovu Taryn Strugnell Marleen Potgieter Wouter Van Heerden Wouter Booysen
Do you have any tips, tools and checklists to use to recruit, manage and motivate employees?[read more]
Published at 10 Sep. 2015 1 answer
My husband works as an engineering manager at a boiler manufacturing company. He has a contract, stating that his...[read more]
Published at 10 Nov. 2015 2 answers
Good day Could you please assist me. In terms of Section 22(3) of the BCEA an employee's sick leave entitlement is...[read more]
Published at 04 Nov. 2015 1 answer
If we have renewed the fixed-term employee's contracts before, can the employee reasonably expect renewal again?[read more]
Published at 08 Sep. 2015 1 answer
I have got a question regarding the employee who was over paid and how do I make him pay back the money and what...[read more]
Published at 12 Oct. 2015 2 answers
we have a sales rep that has a basic plus car allowance and commission, will be going on maternity leave, she earns...[read more]
Published at 21 Oct. 2015 1 answer
Video Archive Video club